Why I hate cruises. (And why I love this one).

Caitlin Sumner of Follow the Goose Travel smiling on a Virgin Voyages balcony at sunset.

Sailing away into the sunset

I need to be very clear about something: I am NOT a cruise person.

I don’t go to the mall when I’m on land, so being trapped inside a floating one for five days is my literal nightmare. I don’t want to be "up-sold" while trying to relax. I don't want to play elbow-tag at a buffet. And I definitely don't want to watch a bad Beatles cover band perform to a crowd reliving their 1985 heyday.

I recently "took one for the team" and sailed on a big mass-market ship (rhymes with "Snore-wegian") to see if anything had changed. Spoiler Alert: It solidified everything I loathe about the industry.

But then... there is the Goose Exception.

Here is the tale of two ships: The one that reminded me why I haven't booked a big line in a decade, and the one that actually meets the "Goose Standard."

The "Ick": The Nickel & Dime Factory (NCL)

The Experience: Imagine a mid-level Vegas resort, but you can't leave.

  • The Crowd: Adult areas were either right next to the screaming kid zones (why?!) or full of drunk assholes by 11:00 AM.

  • The "Value": Everything was extra. You want to play skeeball? Charge. Go-karts? Charge. Waterslide? Charge.

  • The Food: An absolute travesty. The "Specialty Dining" had a $60 per person cover charge for food that was barely edible.

  • The Vibe: Aggressive. I felt like I was being shaken down for lunch money every time I turned a corner.


The "Ahh": The Lady in Red (Virgin Voyages)

Exterior of the Scarlet Lady cruise ship docked in turquoise water.

Scarlet Lady

The Experience: So why am I excited to get back on a ship in April? Because Virgin Voyages isn't a cruise. It's a boutique hotel that happens to float.

From concept to execution, Virgin aligns with my Approachable Luxury ethics in a way no other line does.

The "Come As You Are" Vibe

There are no formal nights. No captains' dinners. No judgment. If you want to wear a caftan (no bra) to get your morning pastry and do a crossword? Do it. If you want to wear Spongebob pajama pants and fuzzy slippers to get avocado toast? I’ve seen it done (by a 62-year-old icon). Virgin creates a space where people of all ages, shapes, and lifestyles just stop giving a f*ck.

Woman wearing a rainbow cape looking at the ocean on a Virgin Voyages cruise, representing the inclusive and LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere.

Always in awe of such beautiful water (Bimini)

Adults Only (For Real)

This ship was designed for us.

  • The Trust Factor: There are board games, puzzles, and backgammon sets left out in the Social Club. No "checkout" system. They treat you like an adult who won't steal the pieces.

  • The Design: No plastic, unbreakable furniture designed for toddlers on a sugar high. It’s luxury finishes, gorgeous upholstery, and spaces meant for conversation, not screaming.

Luxury interior design on Virgin Voyages, showing the high-end staircase and lighting.

The staircase leading to The Wake

The Ethics (Happy Crew = Happy You)

This matters to me. Virgin sailors are the happiest at sea, but so is the crew.

  • No Stripes: There is no stiff hierarchy or military-style uniforms. Crew members can show their tattoos, piercings, and personal style.

  • Inclusion: Pronouns are respected. Diversity is celebrated. It is the most outwardly welcoming environment I have ever experienced at sea.

  • Impact: They don't just dump tourists into a port. Their "Shore Things" program requires operators to adhere to strict sustainability and ethical codes. No exploitative animal encounters. Just authentic connection.

The Value (The Math Maths)

On "Snore-wegian," I felt bled dry. On Virgin, I put my wallet away.

  • No Galley Kitchens: There isn't one giant factory kitchen pumping out rubber chicken. Each of the 20+ eateries has its own kitchen, cooking food to order.

  • The Inclusions: WiFi? Included. Tips? Included. Fitness classes (from Spin to 80s Jazzercise)? Included.

  • The Transparency: I have never "accidentally" gone over budget on Virgin. You can track your bar tab in real-time. No surprise taxes or fees at the end.

A massive Tomahawk steak served table-side at a Virgin Voyages restaurant, showing the high quality of food.

Table-side tomahawk steak

The Golden Egg 🥚: Join the Rebellion

I refuse to sell you a bad vacation. That is why I am extremely selective about who gets the "Goose Stamp of Approval."

If you want to experience the "Anti-Cruise," I have a few cabins left to join me on the Brilliant Lady this April (her "MerMaiden" voyage!).

Don't settle for the mall food court. Come eat steak (or delicious Veg options) with me.

Hit reply with "SAIL AWAY" if you're ready to see the difference.

Cheers,

Caitlin Head Goose

The iconic red hammock on a Virgin Voyages sea terrace balcony.

P.S. 🌊 The Official Goose Calendar (2026 & Beyond)

While I am counting down to April, the rest of the 2026 Sailing Season is already curated. If you want to travel with the Gaggle (or just know which weeks I’ve vetted), here is the lineup:

  • April 7–12, 2026: The Brilliant Lady MerMaiden Voyage (LA). Only a few spots left!

  • July 2026: The "School's Out" Summer Break. Calling all teachers and parents—you need a recess, too. We are chasing hot Caribbean summer vibes (without the kids).

  • October 2026: Halloween in the Eastern Caribbean. 🎃 We are doing spooky season in the sun: Miami > Grand Turk > Puerto Plata > Bimini.

  • January 2027: The "New Year" Wellness Retreat at Sea.

The "Goose Standard" Promise: It isn't just Virgin. I am actively vetting other boutique and exploratory ships (think: intimate river cruises and bucket-list expeditions to Antarctica or the Galapagos). If it has a buffet line or a crowded pool deck, it’s not on the list.

If you are a planner (like me) and want first dibs on any of these dates, hit reply with "FUTURE SAILOR" and I'll add you to the priority list.

Join the Gaggle & Get the Goods.

Two emails a week, zero fluff.
Sundays: "The Sunday Edit" (Travel stories & tea).
Wednesdays: "The Drop" (Exclusive Golden Ticket perks).

Join the Gaggle

I protect my Gaggle. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Previous
Previous

Why the "Leading Ladies" Residency isn't a "Cheap Deal" (And why that's the point).

Next
Next

I’m Back (And We Need to Talk About Who Belongs in "Luxury").